The short answer: Sildenafil (the active ingredient in Viagra) and tadalafil (the active ingredient in Cialis) work the same way, by improving blood flow when you're aroused. The big difference is timing: sildenafil typically works in 30 to 60 minutes and lasts a few hours, while tadalafil can take up to 2 hours but lasts up to 36 hours and also comes as a low-dose daily tablet. At Tides, formulas start at $96 every 4 weeks.
How sildenafil and tadalafil work
Both medications belong to a class called PDE5 inhibitors. During arousal, your body releases signals that relax the blood vessels in the penis so blood can flow in. An enzyme called PDE5 shuts that signal off. Sildenafil and tadalafil block PDE5, so the signal lasts longer and blood flow improves.
That means neither one causes an erection on its own. You still need arousal; the medication just helps your body respond to it. Major urology guidelines include PDE5 inhibitors among the standard treatment options for erectile dysfunction. For background on why ED happens, read our complete guide to sexual health and ED.
Sildenafil vs tadalafil, side by side
| Sildenafil | Tadalafil | |
|---|---|---|
| Brand name | Viagra | Cialis |
| Starts working | About 30 to 60 minutes | Up to 2 hours |
| Window of effect | About 4 to 6 hours | Up to 36 hours |
| Heavy meals | A high-fat meal can slow it down | Less affected by food |
| Daily option | No | Yes, a low-dose daily tablet |
| Side effects more typical of it | Temporary blue-tinged or blurry vision | Back pain or muscle aches |
Speed and duration
Sildenafil is the one to reach for when you can plan ahead by about an hour. Its effect typically lasts a few hours, which is enough for a planned evening.
Tadalafil takes longer to kick in but keeps working for up to 36 hours, which is why it's sometimes called "the weekend pill." Many men prefer it because it takes the clock out of the equation: you don't have to time things around a pill.
Food and alcohol
A large or high-fat meal can delay how quickly sildenafil starts working, so it tends to work best on a lighter stomach. Tadalafil is much less affected by food.
With either medication, a drink or two is usually fine, but heavy drinking makes ED worse on its own and can increase side effects like dizziness and lightheadedness. Ask your provider about your specific formula.
Daily vs. as-needed
Sildenafil is taken as needed, before sex. Tadalafil can be taken either way: as needed at a standard strength, or as a lower-strength tablet once a day so you're ready anytime without planning. At Tides, the Daily Boost tablet is tadalafil taken daily, at $112 for a 28-pack.
Side effects
Both medications share the same common side effects, which are usually mild and short-lived: headache, flushing, a stuffy nose, and an upset stomach. Tadalafil is more likely to cause back or muscle aches. Sildenafil can occasionally cause a temporary blue tint or blurriness in your vision.
Seek emergency care for a severe allergic reaction, any sudden loss of vision or hearing, or an erection lasting more than 4 hours.
Who shouldn't take them
Neither medication is safe with nitrates, often prescribed for chest pain or heart conditions, because the combination can drop blood pressure dangerously. Through Tides, you can't be treated if you take nitrates, had a heart attack or stroke in the past 6 months, have severe or unstable low blood pressure, have severe liver or kidney disease, or have been advised by a doctor not to have sex. Riociguat and alpha-blockers also need a provider's review first.
Which one is right for you?
- Sildenafil may fit if you usually plan ahead, want something that works within the hour, and prefer a shorter window.
- Tadalafil may fit if you value spontaneity, want a longer window, or like the idea of a daily tablet so you never have to time anything.
Research comparing the two finds that both work well. In a large 2015 network meta-analysis, sildenafil ranked slightly higher for effectiveness and tadalafil slightly higher for tolerability, and preference studies show many men lean toward tadalafil for its longer window. The best choice depends on your routine, your health history, and how your body responds, which is exactly what your provider will look at.
Combination formulas
Some men want both: the fast start of sildenafil and the long window of tadalafil. Tides offers compounded formulas that combine them, like the Double Powered tablet (sildenafil and tadalafil) and Triple Powered formulas that add apomorphine or vardenafil, as tablets or liposomal vials. Your provider decides whether a single medication or a combination fits you. Use the ED formula finder to see which one matches how you want it to work.
Compounded formulations are prepared by licensed US pharmacies and prescribed by a licensed provider based on your individual health profile. They are not FDA-approved finished drug products. A prescription is never guaranteed. Individual results vary.
Frequently asked questions
Further reading
- Burnett AL, et al. Erectile dysfunction: AUA guideline. Journal of Urology, 2018.
- Chen L, et al. Phosphodiesterase 5 inhibitors for the treatment of erectile dysfunction: a trade-off network meta-analysis. European Urology, 2015.
- Smith WB, et al. PDE5 inhibitors: considerations for preference and long-term adherence. International Journal of Clinical Practice, 2013.